17.3 C
Monday, June 27, 2022

Magnificent Makin stuns world champion ElShorbagy in Channel VAS

Alan Thatcher
Alan Thatcherhttps://squashmad.com
Founder of World Squash Day, Squash Mad, the Kent Open and co-promoter of the Canary Wharf Classic. Launched the Squash 200 Partnership to build clubs of the future. Talks a bit.

More from the author

Joel Makin goes short against Mohamed ElShorbagy

Welsh wizard wins three tiebreaks against world No.1

World No.33 Joel Makin earned the biggest victory of his career to date after he claimed a dramatic win over World No.1 Mohamed ElShorbagy in Weybridge to send the defending champion out of the Channel VAS Championships at St George’s Hill.

ElShorbagy was coming off the back of a title win at the U.S. Open last week, but the reigning World Champion was under pressure right from the off as Makin combined his typically strong retrieval skills with some fine touches at the front of the court.

After conceding the opener, ElShorbagy showed more of his usual aggression as he came back from 9-4 down in the second to force a tiebreak, but it spilled over as he received a conduct stroke against him after a disagreement with a refereeing decision, which handed the game to Makin.

That moment proved pivotal as Makin doubled his lead and he fought back from three game balls down in the third to complete the win by a 12-10, 13-11, 12-10 scoreline.

“It’s massive [to beat ElShorbagy],” said Makin. “I had a lot of belief and I knew exactly what I needed to do. I really had to be disciplined and I didn’t think about his form, just focused on the process.

“If I was going to get into the match, I had to switch it and keep getting the height. I had to be positive and my short balls were better today than they have been. I’ve been working on them for a long time, but they came together. They were three really tight games.”

Diego Elias downs Daryl Selby

Makin’s reward for his shock victory is a quarter-final meeting with Peru’s Diego Elias after the World No.13 got the better of 2015 runner-up Daryl Selby, winning 11-6, 11-5, 11-5 in 40 minutes.

“I’m very happy to be here again, I haven’t started the season that well, but now I’m feeling better on court,” Elias said.

“Daryl is a super strong player and I think I did a great job beating him in three because it’s always hard. We played here last year in the same round, I knew he wanted revenge but I think I played well.”

World No.8 Paul Coll booked his place in the quarter-finals courtesy of a 3-0 victory over former World No.1 James Willstrop, with the New Zealander avenging his Commonwealth Games defeat to the Englishman in the process.

Paul Coll dives for the ball against James Willstrop

Coll, who shot to prominence by winning this tournament in 2016, went down 3-0 to Willstrop in the final of the Commonwealth Games singles event in April.

But he turned the tide this time around as he came from behind to win a crucial second-game tie-break, before dominating the third to close out the win in straight games.

“[The Commonwealth Games] is always in my mind, it’s one of my ultimate goals in squash, but I’m trying to block that out for another four years and trying not to dwell on that too much because it can release some negative emotions,” said U.S. Open semi-finalist Coll.

“It’s always on my mind, but it’s not what I’m thinking about at all, maybe in four years when I need to light that fire again.”

Coll will play World No.4 Tarek Momen next in a repeat of the 2016 final, with Momen edging Australia’s Cameron Pilley in a tight three-game battle.

Tarek Momen earns a tight win over Cam Pilley

The Egyptian had a 9-3 lead on their head-to-head record coming into the match and, while he was able to extend that lead, he was made to work hard for it by the World No.23, who had only just made his return to action after going through ankle surgery over the summer.

“I must say that I’m very glad to be through, it was one of those where you have to be thankful that you got through because a lot of things were not working,” Momen said afterwards.

“I was trying hard to get into my own rhythm and I couldn’t. He was playing really well considering he had some time off in the summer to have an ankle operation. It’s really good that he’s playing this well with the preparation he’s had.”

The second round of the Channel VAS Championships continues tomorrow (Thursday October 18) and play starts at 17:30 (BST). All of the action will be shown live on SQUASHTV (Rest of World) and Eurosport Player (Europe only). 

PSA Men’s 2018 Channel VAS Championships at St George’s Hill.

Second Round (Top Half):
Joel Makin (WAL) bt [1] Mohamed ElShorbagy (EGY) 3-0: 12-10, 13-11, 12-10 (61m)
[6] Diego Elias (PER) bt Daryl Selby (ENG) 3-0: 11-6, 11-5, 11-5 (40m)
[5] Paul Coll (NZL) bt James Willstrop (ENG) 3-0: 11-7, 12-10, 11-4 (48m)
[3] Tarek Momen (EGY) bt Cameron Pilley (AUS) 3-0: 12-10, 13-11, 12-10 (49m)

Bottom Half (To Be Played October 18):
[4] Karim Abdel Gawad (EGY) v Greg Lobban (SCO)
Mathieu Castagnet (FRA) v [7] Saurav Ghosal (IND)
[8] Omar Mosaad (EGY) v Tom Richards (ENG)
Declan James (ENG) v [2] Ali Farag (EGY)

Draw – Quarter-Finals (Top Half) To Be Played October 19:
Joel Makin (WAL) v [6] Diego Elias (PER)
[5] Paul Coll (NZL) v [3] Tarek Momen (EGY) 

Pictures courtesy of PSA


Related articles


  1. Great effort from Makin, although it’s a shame that the video at that venue doesn’t allow a traditional view of the whole court. A couple of video ref decisions favoured Makin – they weren’t 50:50 calls, but more like 60:40 or 65:35, so Shorbagy was unlucky, but there was nothing outrageous. On at least a couple of the close calls, Shorbagy’s movement back to the T after a loose shot could be considered blocking by a ref trying to enforce access to the ball.

    A well-deserved conduct stroke for Shorbagy, who, bizarrely, went on to claim that the rules don’t allow the ref to give him a conduct stroke without prior warning. For the decision on the last point, he said something like “I already know what your decision is going to be, based on the earlier one” – apparently accusing the video ref of consistency. He also asked “should I just leave?”, and received an answer to that question too.

    A great player, and deservedly the world no. 1, but poor conduct yesterday, and to his own detriment. Compare and contrast to Makin’s restrained reaction to getting a harsh (but technically correct) no let at match ball down in the 5th against Paul Coll at the Commonwealth Games, when the match was on a knife-edge

  2. Sounds like you want to pasteurize the sport and take the personalities out of it.

    You’d probably enjoy current American baseball then.

  3. You seem to be confused, Ted. If you’re looking for a guy who (unlike me) wants to pasteurize the sport, take a look at the quotes from this character (who also, hilariously, thinks tennis has been successfully “pasteurized”)! (PS: His name is Ted Gross.)

    “What a bunch of crap. Yeah, right, buddy, the result was “stolen”.

    “You know what? You don’t want to lose a point – then don’t commit a known conduct violation.
    And players are not entitled to explanations of the rules of squash during the match.”

    “You want players to be able to run roughshod over the refs because it’s ENTERTAINING.
    However, tennis continues to be entertaining, and they’ve curtailed the buffoonery.
    You stop play and approach the chair and argue: It’s point, then game, then match.”

    “it’s common in all sports for fans to bring the officiating into it, when a match or game didn’t go the way they wanted.
    My view is different.”


  4. I knew that would get a rise out of you there, Bud!

    A journeyman knocks off the World No 1, and all you’re concerned with is a player getting chippy after a tough no-stroke reversal at game ball.

    You obviously watched the match – how about a little analysis. Is the other guy suddenly a real contender who can beat Top 20 players?

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Latest articles